Get this book!

constance-markieviczAnne Haverty’s updated new edition of her bio of Constance Markievicz is well worth a read (and a buy). Among other things, Haverty disproves the notion that Markievicz shot an unarmed cop at the beginning of the takeover of Stephen’s Green and then ran back inside the Green exulting in the killing. Personally, I happen to think members of the Dublin Metropoitan Police were legitimate targets, but the attack on Markievicz is that she shot him at point blank range when he was unarmed and had no chance to surrender. Various professional anti-republicans (the historical revisionist school, for instance and folks like Ann Matthews, whom I simply can’t take seriously as any sort of historian) have peddled this nonsense, using highly questionable ‘evidence’.

Haverty runs through, for instance, the use of a Geraldene Fitzgerald’s account which revisionists typically classify as being from her diary. Haverty points out that it is actually two typed pages that read like a deposition for a prosecution, one the state did not pursue (which itself says something about the fanciful nature of the claim). Haverty shows how Fitzgerald’s testimony is faulty (different time to when the policeman was actually shot; distance from the shooting and yet Fitzgerald claimed to hear words spoken in the Green!!!) and concludes of Fitzgerald’s ‘evidence’: “Only the obstinately mischievous, to put it kindly, can continue to cite it.”

Brian Barton, the historian who unearthed the official British court-martial records, has already exposed the lie that Markievicz broke down and whimpered for her life at her court-martial.

Matthews, however, is on a mission – to try to destroy the reputations of the republican women of the early 1900s, so facts are of no interest to her.  And the revisionists just hate republicanism, period.

Also look out for Lindie Naughton’s book on Markievicz, which is coming out in September, published by Merrion Press.

 

Advertisements

Posted on July 1, 2016, in 1913 lockout, British state repression (general), Censorship, Civil War period, Constance Markievicz, Counter-revolution/civil war period, Free State in 1920s, 1930s and 1940s, General revolutionary history, Historiography and historical texts, Irish Citizen Army, Irish politics today, national, Political education and theory, Prisoners - past, Republicanism post-1900, The road to the Easter Rising, Toadyism, War for Independence period, Women, Women in republican history, Women prisoners. Bookmark the permalink. Comments Off on Get this book!.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: